The most popular squareCircleZ math blog post in 2007
By Murray Bourne, 30 Dec 2007
Sol Lederman over at WildAboutMath issued a challenge: Math bloggers: What was your most popular post in 2007?
Now there are several issues raised with this task. What does "most popular post" mean? Some of the complications:
- Does "popular" mean "most visited"? [Just because a post is visited by a browser, it doesn't mean the reader read all of the post - or any of it, for that matter. Most Web users are 'peckers' - 10 seconds and if it doesn't grab them, they are out of there.]
- Therefore, does "popular" mean "spent most time on the post"? [If they spent a lot of time, it probably means they actually read it and possibly even read parts of it more than once.]
- Does "popular" include a consideration of "loyalty"? [If all readers are 'one time only' visitors, the post could be popular due to good search engine optimisation.]
- A lot of people use blog aggregators, blog email feeds, personal homepages (that include an aggregators), etc. Some (and possibly all) of these do not necessarily register as a 'hit' on the actual blog statistics.
- Does "popular" mean "most commented"? [A post might be liked, but most readers may have nothing more to add.]
Anyway, I'll report on what I know. Here's what squareCircleZ looked like during 2007.
The posts which had the most visits during 2007 (some of these posts were written in 2006 but are still going strong):
- Which websites are most popular in Singapore? [Web stats are fascinating and this is a growth area for math students]
- Peddlers of Cancer [where i rail against the tobacco industry]
- Phase shift or phase angle? [where some much needed clarification of vocabulary ensues]
- Fractal tattoos [this continues to be popular, especially as tattoos become more mainstream]
Most Commented Posts
The posts which caused the most discussion were:
- Towards more meaningful math notation (18) [I'm glad this sparked some interest - I think it is an important issue that math educationists should tackle]
- Microsoft Math 3.0 Review (14) [Vlorbic claimed that the software looked like 'the opposite of helpful'. Is it? Surely it depends a lot on how it is used.]
- Boxing equals brain damage (10) [Where some enthusiasts did not take kindly to my criticism of the 'sport'.]
- The Carnival of Mathematics äºŒå (#20) (10) [It was fun to put this together]
- Algebrator review (9) [Where the vendor obtained some feedback. Vlorbic was still not impressed: "looks worse than useless to me"]
The dates where visitors stayed the longest on the site on average were (according to Google Analytics):
- Sat 17 Nov 2007 (the post on that day was Interactive 3D math simulations)
- Sat 3 Nov 2007 (that day's post was The Carnival of Mathematics äºŒå (#20))
- Sat 20 Oct 2007 (the previous day's post was Friday math movie - the Rain Man in each of us
Of course, visitors could have been staying long on those days for some other post(s). It's interesting that each one is a Saturday.
Country of Visitor Origin
In order, the most visitors came from:
- United States
- Hong Kong
- Great Britain
My Favourite Post for 2007
There's a recency effect here I guess, but this week's Friday Math Movie is by yours truly.
Check it out: It's an introduction to the concepts behind Trigonometric Graphs.
Happy New Year, everyone!
See the 1 Comment below.
3 Jan 2008 at 2:56 am [Comment permalink]
let me clarify:
i *am* impressed by neven jurkovic's
participation in the algebrator thread
(but not enough to shame me into
defending my kneejerk reaction --
"the opposite of helpful" -- what can i say?
all this computo stuff is hard to learn
and *changes the subject* [and is expensive
and soon outdated and ugly ...] ... nothing
in particular against your particular product
buddy ... just that it makes *my* job harder ...).